Critique

Project Aquila

Mechanics:
They used a digital prototype instead of paper
have keyboard and control

Dyanamics:
have a good variouty of units that have different attributes

Aesthetics:
Players who did the test became more involved in this game once they figured out how the mechanic works


Project Chopstick Chung

Mechanics:
They also used digital prototype
Use mouse to try to hit a fly

Dyanmics:
hit box is too small, also 100 pixels too low
player found it hard to immerse

Aesthetics:
game is very addictive
interesting to see what other minigames they are creating


Project Deep Field

Mechanics:
They used a physical game where player is surrunded 360 degrees with team members who are moving slowly toward the player, and the player have to push them away

Dynamics:
constantly changing height of the balls to increase challenge
Player can choose to use either one hand or both depend on the difficulty level, which I found to be quite interesting.

Aesthetics:
Very interesting game concept.
Mechanic is simple yet fun

Project Dynasty

Mechanics:
They used a board game with grids.
They have fog of war to keep traps hidden
Collecting URLs

Dynamics:
After completing an objective, the player gains better instructions

Aesthetics:
History based game.
Intersting to see how the game turns out