Critiques

Project Antlion

Mechanics:
I board game with grid
Player move through the board and need to watch out for antlions

Dynamics:
They prototype represent a very early version of the game
Unsure of what the player should be

Aesthetics:
The group need to make dicisions fast on what the game is going to be
Educational game turns me off
Hopefully the final game will look more interesting then the paper version

Fins of Fury

My project.


Project Mizu

Mechanics:
Player uses water to both move and fight the enemies
Paper prototype don't represent the real game
Enemies are controled by dice rolls in paper prototype

Dynamics:
Nice reward for killing the enemies
Nice idea to ride a turtle

Aesthetics:
Game may easily become too easy, but if balanced well, could be a great game
Artword is definitly an A+, really like the whole style of the game


Project Untitled

Mechanics:
Player fights in a small classroom
Kind like many old school arcade fighting games

Dynamics:
No rewards from killing the enemies
Players fight till they dies

Aesthetics:
Too many puzzles in game causes distraction
Need to be able to heal the player or they won't last long
More loot from the enemies will encurage the player to continue to play.